top of page

Stakeholder Analysis: “The individual is a grain of sand”

image.png

Services did not appear to be immediately accessible in the under-served communities where we worked. We mapped relationships and interactions between various actors and institutions. We explored how individual willpower needs to be met with accessible services. Combined with macro level factors and forces, these constrain people's agency for cessation.

The “big players” in smoking and smoking cessation were identified in the Venn diagram (bigger circles highlighted in yellow). These included the tobacco and e-cigarette manufacturers, whose main objective is to profit from selling tobacco and related products. Overlapping with tobacco companies, the next “big player” included the Government, seen as the institution that has the power to limit the affordability of cigarettes (e.g., by increasing tax).

 

In terms of services including smoking cessation, peer support groups were seen as non-existent (green circles). Online information was discussed as a key source and potential strategy for quitting - ‘you go online for all information’, and that everyone has access. However, there were positives and negatives related to online information, help was available but the internet also provides ease of access to e-cigarettes online.

Participants expressed that ‘the individual is a grain of sand’ compared to the 'bigger players' who influence policy, marketing and availability of tobacco and related products. Individuals need their support to be successful. “We can have all the willpower but we need the support of other elements to be successful”.

Cost of Living/Cost of Smoking: participatory research on smoking in deprived communities within the cost-of-living crisis.  This study is organised by the University of Aberdeen in partnership with Action on Smoking and Health (ASH) Scotland, NHS Grampian, and Turning Point Scotland (TPS). It is funded by ASH Scotland, the British Heart Foundation (BHF) and Cancer Research UK (CRUK). Study ID Code School Ethics Review Board Reference (SERB): 652990

© 2023 University of Aberdeen

All rights reserved.

bottom of page